Old Fashioned Penny Candy

Starburst Fruit Chews Candy: 3LB Bag

14 Reviews
$15.50

Jolly Rancher Hard Candy Assortment: 5LB Bag

35 Reviews
$22.95

Salt Water Taffy - Assorted Flavors: 5LB Bag

67 Reviews
$22.95

Assorted Salt Water Taffy Candy: 3LB Bag

41 Reviews
$13.95

Dum Dums Original Pops Ball Lollipops: 300-Piece Bag

12 Reviews
$17.95

Bit-O-Honey Candy: 5LB Bag

17 Reviews
$28.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Blue Raspberry: 360-Piece Bag

26 Reviews
$11.95

Dubble Bubble Bubblegum: 5LB Bag

5 Reviews
$22.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Strawberry Lemonade: 360-Piece Bag

26 Reviews
$11.95

Goetze's Caramel Creams Bulls Eyes Candy - Vanilla: 5LB Bag

31 Reviews
$22.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Watermelon: 360-Piece Bag

2 Reviews
$11.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Strawberry: 360-Piece Bag

10 Reviews
$11.95

Kraft Caramel Squares Candy: 11-Ounce Bag

2 Reviews
$5.95

Key Lime Drops Candy: 5LB Bag

57 Reviews
$17.95

Tootsie Fruit Rolls Candy: 37-Ounce Bag

7 Reviews
$11.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Fruit Punch: 360-Piece Bag

5 Reviews
$11.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Grape: 360-Piece Bag

32 Reviews
$11.95

Spi-C-Mints Starlight Mints Candy: 5LB Bag

35 Reviews
$17.95

Smarties Candy Mini Rolls: 160-Piece Box

2 Reviews
$18.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Mango: 360-Piece Bag

2 Reviews
$11.95

Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Peppermint: 5LB Bag

21 Reviews
$28.95

PEZ Fruity Candy Refills 6-Packs: 12-Piece Box

9 Reviews
$28.50

Salt Water Taffy - Peanut Butter: 2.5LB Bag

2 Reviews
$11.95

Salt Water Taffy - Root Beer Float: 2.5LB Bag

$11.95

Tootsie Roll Frooties Candy - Lemon Lime: 360-Piece Bag

1 Review
$11.95

Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Rainbow Cherry: 5LB Bag

3 Reviews
$28.95

Wax Lips Candy: 24-Piece Box

5 Reviews
$35.50

Salt Water Taffy - Sugar Cookie: 2.5LB Bag

$11.95

Double Lollies Candy: 200-Piece Tub

10 Reviews
$35.50

PEZ Fruity Candy Rolls: 400-Piece Case

20 Reviews
$56.50

Atkinson Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars Candy: 3LB Bag

5 Reviews
$34.95

Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Fruitie Tootie: 5LB Bag

3 Reviews
$28.95

Espeez Cube Pops - Groovy Tie-Dye: 48-Piece Display

4 Reviews
$33.95

Toxic Waste Sour Candy Packs: 1000-Piece Bag

$58.50

Atkinson Hard Candy Twists - Wintergreen: 5LB Bag

4 Reviews
$28.95

Atkinson Coconut Long Boys Candy: 48-Piece Display

16 Reviews
$11.50

Smarties Candy Rolls: 180-Piece Tub

3 Reviews
$31.95

Arcor Honey Drops Hard Candy: 6-Ounce Bag

2 Reviews
$4.50

Espeez Money Mints Candy 2-Packs: 240-Piece Bag

1 Review
$56.50

Espeez Money Mints Rolls: 100-Piece Tub

3 Reviews
$52.95

Starburst Fruit Chews Candy Fun Size Packs: 25LB Case

$151.95

Slo Poke Bite Size Caramel Candy: 5LB Bag

3 Reviews
$34.95

Atkinson Cherry Hard Candy Buttons: 5LB Bag

$28.95

Fralinger's Salt Water Taffy: 5LB Bag

3 Reviews
$57.95

Atkinson Hot Cinnamon Hard Candy Buttons: 5LB Bag

9 Reviews
$28.95

Chocolate Caramel Squares Candy: 5LB Bag

18 Reviews
$28.95

Arcor Chewy Fruities Candy: 6-Ounce Bag

1 Review
$4.50

Necco Mary Jane Candy: 30LB Case

1 Review
$138.95
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 5

Our love affair with candy is far from new, especially if it’s penny candy. For several millennia, humans have been splurging on sweets, and we aim to keep the tradition going. Candy Warehouse carries a large assortment of small sugar candies that you may know better by another name. Penny candy has a long and celebrated history, but the term encompasses quite the variety of individually wrapped treats. Originally, confectioners and candy shops would sell these candies for a penny. Before you whip out the calculator to check for inflation, you should shop from our selection to relive the glory days. We carry all the name brands you know and love, including Bit O Honey, Chick-O-Stick, Dubble Bubble, Mary Janes, and so much more. Explore our candy collection today!

Sign Up For Special Offers & Delicious Candy!