enter your email address and we'll send you your shopping cart:

Item Added to Cart
(16 of 20)

Peanut Butter Candy

+ Read More
Peanut butter and childhood seem to go together like milk and cookies. If you’re feeling nostalgic for all those peanut butter treats you enjoyed as a kid, CandyWarehouse.com has the solution for you. We offer a wide selection of candy with peanut butter by the best brands in confectionery heaven, including Butterfinger®, Reese’s®, Snickers®, and so much more. Did you know that peanut butter dates back to the Aztec times? The Aztecs would mash roasted peanuts into a paste. It wasn’t until the nineteenth century that inventors created a process of manufacturing and the machinery needed to make it. When you don’t have the time for a classic PB&J, grab some peanut butter candy to satisfy your cravings. Shop from our selection of peanut butter candies today to find all your favorite snacks.

There are few peanut butter candy brands that are as well-known as Reese’s®, and we offer one of the largest online selections of their addicting products. Those sinfully delicious peanut butter cups are enough to make you daydream, but that’s not all we have in store for you. We carry Reese’s® Pieces, Crunchers, and other candy with peanut butter that will leave your taste buds begging for more with every bite. We also offer their entire line of the peanut butter cup varieties, including white chocolate, dark chocolate, and their famous milk chocolate. If you’re planning your wedding or a large event, you can create a colorful candy bar with the help of our peanut butter cup color combinations.

Our peanut butter candy collection wouldn’t be complete without selections from Baby Ruth®, M&M’S®, PAYDAY®, and other brands, as well as malt balls, chocolate peanut clusters, toffee, truffles, and other sweets. If you’re looking for a gag gift to rule them all, look no further than our jumbo two-pound milk chocolate peanut butter cup. Don’t forget to stock up on all your favorite peanut butter candies before National Peanut Butter Day! While shopping, remember to register your account so you can log multiple shipping addresses and track orders with ease. Please contact us if you have any questions about this product selection or shipping. A candy expert is here to help!
Sort By
Chupa Chups Lolllipops
Haribo Gummy
Hershey's Kisses
Jolly Rancher Candy
PEZ Candy
Sour Patch Candy
Starburst Candy
Swedish Fish Candy
Tootsie Roll Industries
Twizzlers Candy